What I don't get is why Benitez got warm and then sat back down. If he isn't ready to go back-to-back quite yet, I understand that, but it's strange to see someone getting loose in the 9th if there's no intention to bring him in.

If Benitez had given it up, I'd be able to accept it more than having about our 6th best reliever give it up. At least Armando is a bona fide closer, albeit a still healing one.